3 posts
• Page **1** of **1**

Be the first to discuss this question!

- admin
**Posts:**1065**Joined:**Tue Jun 29, 2010 7:47 pm

Hi,

I'm just wondering for q14 how you get the answer to be (M1+M2+M3)g.

when filled into the F=MA equation I get: (M1+M2+M3)g = MA

So to get A on its own I must divide by M1 and then would end up with (M2+M3)g?

Thank you

I'm just wondering for q14 how you get the answer to be (M1+M2+M3)g.

when filled into the F=MA equation I get: (M1+M2+M3)g = MA

So to get A on its own I must divide by M1 and then would end up with (M2+M3)g?

Thank you

- Laura_2707
**Posts:**9**Joined:**Thu Aug 27, 2020 11:25 pm

Laura_2707 wrote:Hi,

I'm just wondering for q14 how you get the answer to be (M1+M2+M3)g.

when filled into the F=MA equation I get: (M1+M2+M3)g = MA

So to get A on its own I must divide by M1 and then would end up with (M2+M3)g?

Thank you

There are several issues with the reasoning above, first the maths:

If

(M1+M2+M3)g = MA

to isolate A, you must divide both sides by M:

(M1+M2+M3)/M x g = A

but if you meant M to be M1 then

(M1+M2+M3)/M1 x g = A (the M1's cannot cancel)

However, this statement is not correct:

(M1+M2+M3)g = MA

because: how is M1, which is on the ground, have its acceleration affected by gravity? It is not as direct as you have it above (it must involve friction, and so the coefficient of friction).

And the funny part: This question needs no calculation, the work was already done. Here is the key, from the passage: "The external force F is such that m3 neither rises nor falls." If m3 is not going up or down, then m2 is not moving relative to m1. That means that the acceleration of m2 is identical to that of m1. And since we already calculated the acceleration of m2 in the previous question, the acceleration of m1 is the same.

PS: You are making good progress through the practice material! I'm hoping that you have done, or are doing, the same progress through the GAMSAT-level practice questions in the books, while taking brief notes (and, studying from those notes 3 times/week, from the start, until your exam date). Keep up the good work!

- goldstanda3269
**Posts:**1646**Joined:**Wed Aug 25, 2010 10:59 pm

3 posts
• Page **1** of **1**

Return to Section III: Reasoning in Biological and Physical Sciences

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest